She Tried the 75 Soft Challenge and "Actually Craves Healthy Food Now"

Standing in front of the mirror, Amanda Castillo wasn't unhappy with her reflection, but she wanted more energy and strength. Like many of us, she had tried various fitness programs before, but this time she chose a different path. The food and wellness enthusiast, with over 300,000 YouTube subscribers, decided to try the 75 Soft Challenge – a gentler approach to lifestyle transformation that's gaining attention for its sustainable results.

It Started as 75 Hard Challenge

The 75 Hard Challenge, created by entrepreneur Andy Frisella in 2019, is an intense program requiring two 45-minute workouts daily, a strict diet with no alcohol or cheat meals, drinking a gallon of water, reading ten pages of nonfiction, and taking progress pictures – all for 75 days without missing a single task. Miss one requirement, and you start over from day one.

Then a Softer Version Emerged

In response to concerns about this extreme approach, the 75 Soft Challenge emerged as a more sustainable alternative. As Cleveland Clinic explains, "Something like 75 Soft is perhaps more in line with general health guidelines and offers a much safer way to achieve your goals."

"I wanted to get toned, build some muscle, and yes, get abs – I mean, we all want abs," Amanda shares with a laugh. The challenge consists of four main rules: a 45-minute daily workout (with rest days allowed), reading 10 pages of any book, drinking three liters of water, and making healthy food swaps without strict restrictions.

The Science of Sustainable Change

Health and sports psychologist Matthew Sacco, PhD, emphasizes why programs like 75 Soft work: "When we're able to accommodate these changes in our life and make it a part of what we're regularly doing, it comes a lot easier over time." This aligned perfectly with Amanda's approach: "I just wanted to try this challenge and see if I could even do it."

Tracking Progress: Beyond the Scale

"I wanted to do this because we all know that the scale does not give you the full picture," Amanda explains. Her initial InBody scan showed 144.2 pounds with 33.4% body fat. This scientific approach to tracking progress proved crucial for maintaining motivation throughout the journey.

Early Days and First Challenges

"I was so motivated in these first two weeks," Amanda shares. "I was not missing a workout. I was getting into my reading." She started with the book, which she describes as her "Bible." However, real life soon tested her commitment to festivals and work commitments.

Creating a Sustainable Routine

"I ended up doing my own workout routine," Amanda explains. "I dove into so many TikTok workout routines, a lot of YouTube workout routines, and I just pretty much copied and pasted and did whatever felt right to me." She emphasizes preparation: "I wanted to go to the gym every day with a plan."

The Power of Rest and Recovery

Unlike more extreme challenges, 75 Soft incorporates active recovery days. Dr. Sacco notes, "Sometimes, that looks like walking around the block three times a week for two weeks and then scaling that up when you're comfortable." This approach helped Amanda maintain consistency without burnout.

RELATED: She Could Have Lost Weight Faster If She Had Known These 5 Fat Loss Tricks

The Food Revolution

"I actually crave healthy food now," Amanda reveals. Rather than following an overly restrictive diet, she made sustainable changes. "It's really wild to me how we can condition our bodies to live and eat a certain way," she adds. This approach aligns with Dr. Sacco's advice about making small, sustainable changes that last.

Physical Results That Matter

After 75 days, Amanda's transformation was clear. While she lost just 4 pounds overall, she shed 8 pounds of fat and gained 2 pounds of muscle. Her body fat percentage decreased to 28.9%. "Who cares if it's not the biggest difference in numbers? They're going down. That's what we want to see," she reflects.

Mental Transformation

"I've been sleeping better. My energy's been higher. I love working out now," Amanda shares. Dr. Sacco explains why this matters: "What actually builds resilience is having the ability to bounce back when something happens. That's going to be more sustainable in the long haul."

RELATED: 10 Warning Signs Your Calories Are Dangerously Low

The Journey Continues

"It's not about being perfect," Amanda emphasizes, "it's just about doing it, about being consistent." This echoes Dr. Sacco's wisdom: "None of us are perfect, and the idea of being perfect, even for something like 75 days, is very difficult."

The challenge might end, but Amanda's story shows that the habits can last. As she concludes, "I am just so thankful for what I've gained from this challenge. The challenge might end, but the habits stay with you." Her journey demonstrates what experts at Cleveland Clinic emphasize: giving yourself grace and flexibility while maintaining consistency leads to lasting change. And if you enjoyed this article, don't miss 12-3-30 Walking Method: 20 Proven Tips to Lose Weight Faster.